The best pizzas in Chicago right now (2024)

The best pizzas in Chicago right now (1)

Photograph: Garrett Sweet

From saucy deep dish to flame-kissed Neapolitan pies, these are the best slices (and squares) in Chicago.

Written by Morgan Olsen

Global Food & Drink Editor

Contributors: Samantha Nelson & Jeffy Mai

Advertising

The question of who dishes out the best pizza in Chicago is a contentious one, spurring arguments about what’s the best regional style and what restaurants do each version justice. Almostevery Chicagoan has a strong preference when it comes to who serves thebest deep dish pizza, but the city’s pizza scene casts a wide net. Thin crust, tavern-style has its own claim to being the real Chicago-style pizza, and you can also find the city's bestItalian restaurants serving traditional Neapolitan pies, Detroit-style squares loaded with quirky toppings, and even New York-style slices. Whether you’re ordering takeout or delivery or plan to dig in while the cheese is still bubbling, check out our guide to the best pizza spots in Chicago to find your new favorite.

RECOMMENDED:Discover more of the best restaurants in Chicago

Been there, done that? Think again, my friend.

By entering your email address you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and consent to receive emails from Time Out about news, events, offers and partner promotions.

🙌
Awesome, you're subscribed!

Thanks for subscribing! Look out for your first newsletter in your inbox soon!

Top pizzas in Chicago

1.Vito and Nick’s Pizzeria
  • Pizza
  • Ashburn
  • price 1 of 4

Photograph: Martha Williams

Tossing and saucing pies since 1946, Ashburn shop Vito and Nick’s is the king of tavern-style 'za. The crispy, cracker-thin crust, tangy sauce and top-quality sausage separate this pizza from its peers. The cash-only joint doesn't do delivery (a promise co-founder Nick Barracao made back in '65), so pick up the phone and call in your carryout order or plan a visit to the no-frills dining room—a pitcher of beer and an order of cheese sticks will tide you over while you wait for the main event.

Morgan Olsen
Global Food & Drink Editor

2.Milly's Pizza in the Pan
  • Pizza
  • Uptown
  • price 2 of 4

Photograph: Garrett Sweet

If you’ve lived in Chicago long enough, chances are you already have a favorite pan pizza. Milly’s fantastic pies, though, may test your allegiances. Owner Robert Maleski started making pizzas during the pandemic in a ghost kitchen and now has his own restaurants in Uptown and Berwyn. Inspired by local legend Burt Katz, the dough is baked with a ring of mozzarella around it, resulting in a caramelized crust. Maleski tops the cheese and sauce with a host of ingredients and dollops of fresh mozzarella. We’re big fans of the Craiglist.org, a winning combination of sausage, mushrooms, peppadew peppers, red onions, tomatoes, spinach and ricotta. Availability is limited, so it’s best to order ahead.

Jeffy Mai
Editor, Time Out Chicago

Advertising

3.Middle Brow Bungalow
  • Breweries
  • Logan Square
Photograph: Jaclyn Rivas

The char-dappled pies at this Logan Square brewery might just rival the beer that Middle Brow is best known for. Expect a short but sweet menu of options, like the classic margherita with fresh mozzarella and basil or the mushroom with melty fontina and caramelized onions. And because the dough's made in-house daily, there's not a dud on the menu. The only mistake you can make is not pairing your 'za with a beer: The Tackle Box lager is just right for a picnic at nearby Palmer Square Park.Drop in on Tuesdays for tavern-style pizzas.

Morgan Olsen
Global Food & Drink Editor

4.Professor Pizza
  • Pizza
  • Lincoln Park
Photograph: Courtesy of Professor Pizza

Anthony Scardino, affectionately known as Professor Pizza, is a champion pizza maker who’s been quietly turning out some of the best pies in the city. You can order them in several varieties—including New York, Detroit and Sicilian-style—but our favorite is the grandma-style. Pep fans should definitely try the Deluxe Pepperoni, which comes loaded with cups plus whipped ricotta and hot honey. Professor Pizza is located in Old Town and also provides the food for seasonal West Loop rooftop Tetto.

Advertising

5.Paulie Gee’s
  • Pizza
  • Logan Square
  • price 2 of 4

Photograph: Courtesy Paulie Gee's Logan Square

Brooklyn import Paulie Gee’s serves a wide-selection of Neapolitan-inspired wood-fired pizzas like the signature Hellboy with soppressata picante and Mike’s Hot Honey or the vegan Fast Car with garlic, mushrooms, sauteed bread crumbs and cashew ricotta dollops. You’ll also find Logan Squares, a riff on Detroit’s thick crust rectangular pizzas, that can be made vegan or with gluten-free dough. If you’re looking for a New York-style slice, head to Paulie Gee’s Wicker Park location, which also offers breakfast sandwiches on weekend mornings.

Samantha Nelson

6.Pequod’s Pizza
  • Pizza
  • Lincoln Park
  • price 1 of 4

Photograph: Martha Williams for Time Out

If you ask an honest-to-god Chicagoan to name their favorite deep dish pizza, chances are they'll point you to Pequod's, where the signature pan pies are ringed with caramelized cheese and the slices are massive—one piece makes a meal. Add veggies to lighten it up a bit, or go all in, with the sausage pie, dotted with perfectly spiced, ping-pong ball–size pieces of seasoned ground pork. It's not hard to see what all the fuss is about.

Morgan Olsen
Global Food & Drink Editor

Advertising

7.Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe
  • Pizza
  • Lincoln Square
  • price 1 of 4

Photograph: Martha Williams

After more than a decade in Lincoln Square, Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe moved to bigger digs in Ravenswood in 2022 and now has more seating and additional ovens to keep up with demand for its New York-style pizza. Sidle up to the counter and craft your own pie or try a slice of one of their specialties like the BDW made with chopped dates, applewood bacon, crushed walnuts, gorgonzola and Mike’s Hot Honey, or the Windy City, which features housemade sausage, mushrooms and roasted red pepper.

Samantha Nelson

8.Spacca Napoli
  • Pizza
  • Uptown
  • price 2 of 4

Photograph: Martha Williams for Time Out

This place is serious about Neapolitan 'za: A custom-built, oak-stoked oven kicks out bubbling beauties with perfectly charred peaks and valleys in less than two minutes. The hand-formed crust is paper-thin at the center, thicker toward the edges and has the unmistakable chew of a true Neapolitan pie. Aside from the simple marinara or Margherita, toppings run the gamut from anchovies to rapini to pistachio cream. Add on a bottle of Italian wine and tiramisu and limoncello to finish off your dinner, and you’ve got a great night out.

Advertising

9.Pat’s Pizza and Ristorante
  • Pizza
  • Sheffield & DePaul
  • price 1 of 4

Photograph: Brendan Lekan

We’re not advocating taking Roger Ebert’s advice on pizza, but we will give some credence to his claim that there’s a good thin-crust pie to be found here. Pastas, salads and a handful of cheesy, sauced chicken entrées round out the options, but we suggest sticking with the pizza, especially if you’re a fan of crispy paper-thin crust and square-cut slices. Order a vegetarian versionor one topped with crumbled Italian sausage, plus plenty of beers to wash it down, and you’re in for a wallet-friendly night in a good old-fashioned family-friendly joint.

Morgan Olsen
Global Food & Drink Editor

10.Zazas Pizzeria
  • Pizza
  • Lake View
Photograph: Courtesy Zazas Pizzeria

Locals may never see eye to eye with New Yorkers when it comes to pizza, but Zazas is certainly doing its best to be the great unifier. The Lakeview pizzeria makes remarkable New York-style pies that will impress even the most diehard supporters of deep dish and tavern style. The crust is brushed with herb-infused olive oil and stands up to the toppings—which include giardiniera, calabrian chili and shaved parmesan—so you won’t be getting any floppy slices. Build your own pizza or go with one of the original creations like the Truffle Mushroom Pie (garlic cream, mozzarella, cremini mushrooms, goat cheese, truffle oil, chives).

Advertising

11.George's Deep Dish
  • Pizza
  • Edgewater
Photograph: Courtesy of George's Deep Dish

At this small Edgewater spot, the deep dish pizzas are unlike any other in town. Owner George Bumbaris uses a sourdough starter and recipe that’s based on lagana—a Greek flatbread similar to focaccia. The bottom of each pie is also dusted with cornmeal while the edges of the crust are caramelized. And instead of putting the toppings under the sweet red sauce, Bumbaris layers them over it. The menu pays tribute to famous Georges throughout history with fun creations likeClooney's ER (Ezzo cup and char pepperoni, Italian sausage, meatballs, bacon) and Michael’s S&M (spaghetti, meatballs, ricotta, roasted garlic).

Jeffy Mai
Editor, Time Out Chicago

12.Villa Nova
  • Pizza
  • Brighton Park

Golf ball-sized pieces of sausage are arranged in a neat grid atop thin crust at Villa Nova, which has been serving some of the best tavern-style pizza in the Chicago suburbs since 1955. Those who prefer a slightly thicker crust can opt for the double dough to load up with extra toppings like giardiniera and green olives. There’s no dining room, so order aheadfor pickup.

Samantha Nelson

Advertising

13.Coalfire
  • Pizza
  • River West/West Town
  • price 2 of 4

Photograph: Jaclyn Rivas for Time Out

Coalfire comes out among the top of the thin-crust pizza joints in Chicago. The little spot in West Town (with a second location in Southport Corridor) turns out blistered pies with a chewy, slightly crisp edge from its 800-degree coal oven. While the crust is a work of art itself, the toppings are inspired—soft whipped peaks of ricotta balance coins of spicy pepperoni; thin slices of fiery 'nduja, a spreadable Calabrian salami, with fresh mozzarella; and a garlicky white pie are among the standouts.

Morgan Olsen
Global Food & Drink Editor

14.Bonci Pizzeria
  • Pizza
  • West Loop
Arianna Giuntini

Bonci is the 31 Flavors of pizza, in a more elevated, carbo-loaded sort of way. No two visits are the same, thanks to a rotating cast of Roman pies that guests are invited to order by the strip. The crust eats like focaccia, and you can expect to find classic and imaginative toppings like crispy potatoes, spicy eggplant, silky lox and creamy ricotta. Three or four strips is the perfect serving for a hungry adult, and the staff at Bonci is happy to heat them up on-site or give you detailed instructions to do it at home.

Advertising

15.Robert’s Pizza Company
  • Pizza
  • Streeterville
  • price 2 of 4

Photograph: Courtesy Robert's Pizza

The Chicago-New York pizza rivalry runs deep, but every once in a while, us Midwesterners fall in love with an East Coast import. So is the case with New Yorker Robert Garvey's riverfront Streeterville pie shop. You see, Garvey is a certified pizzaioli who spent nearly 20 years developing an anatomically perfect crust. Cooked in a brick oven, these thin-crust pizzas boast the right crunch-to-chew ratio and are dressed up in a slew of creative toppings. You can create your own, but why bother? Garvey has dreamed up a laundry list of delicious pairings, like the duck prosciutto with calabrian chile, fresh mozzarella and tomato sauce.

Morgan Olsen
Global Food & Drink Editor

16.My Pi Pizza
  • Pizza
  • Bucktown
  • price 2 of 4

Photograph: Courtesy of My Pi

Since 1971, My Pi Pizza has been serving deep dish made with dough baked fresh each day with three rises, so the crust is sturdy enough to contain the layers of Wisconsin cheese, secret tomato sauce blend and other toppings like roast beef, giardiniera and artichokes. The restaurant also offers a full vegan menu featuring deep dish and a thin-crust pie perfect for one, plus white chocolate chip cookies made with flaxseed. Get your pizza to go or eat it straight from the pan inthetent out front.

Samantha Nelson

Advertising

17.Labriola Ristorante and Cafe
  • Italian
  • Streeterville
Photograph: Hannah Hornacek

Labriola offers four different styles of pizza for those who just can’t choose a favorite. Do a side-by-side comparison with Chicago-style thin crust, deep dish, skinny deep dish with less dough but the same cheesy crust, or ciabatta-style dough. The restaurant even offers a gluten-free crust. Located right off Michigan Avenue,Labriola's dog-friendly patio also provides great views. After your meal, grab a treat from sibling spot Stan’sDonuts to enjoy later.

Samantha Nelson

18.Lou Malnati’s
  • Pizza
  • Loop
  • price 2 of 4

Photograph: Martha Williams for Time Out

There are two kinds of Chicagoans: Giordano’s people and Lou Malnati’s people. Lou's has been slinging deep dish pies since 1971 and is known for its flaky, buttery crust. Each pizza is stuffed with fresh mozzarella cheese from Wisconsin, vine-ripened California tomatoes and an exclusive sausage blend. Don't fuss with anything else on the menu—including pasta dishes or thin-crust 'za. A large deep dish pizza easily serves (and fills) four hungry adults.

Morgan Olsen
Global Food & Drink Editor

Advertising

19.Bob’s Pizza
  • Pizza
  • Lower West Side
  • price 2 of 4

Photograph: Courtesy Bob's PIzza

Bob’s Pizza executive chef/partner Matt Wilde developed his own Pilsen-style pizza by replacing water in the dough with Old Style beer. The result is a 16-inch pie that has the thickness of a New York-style slice but the puffy crust found in Neapolitan pizzas. With locations across the city and suburbs, Bob’s serves quirky creations, including the Pickle Pizza made with garlic cream, mortadella, sliced pickles and fresh dill, and the Spinach Pesto and Stracciatella Pizza featuring prosciutto, spinach pesto, sun-dried tomatoes, stracciatella cheese, house-blend cheese and baby arugula.

Samantha Nelson

20.Five Squared Pizza
  • Pizza
  • River North
  • price 2 of 4

Photograph: Kristen Mendiola

Ideal for the indecisive, Five Squared Pizza lets you select four different Detroit-style slices per box, and the flavors available are anything but ordinary. The Spacca is loaded with pistachio cream sauce, Italian sausage, burrata, hot honey and basil, while the Tie Dye comes topped with homemade red sauce, vodka sauce and pesto. A new menu goes live every month, and pickup and delivery is available Wednesday through Saturday. You can also findFive Squared pies at Off Color Brewing Thursday through Saturday.

Advertising

21.Phil’s Pizza
  • Pizza
  • Bridgeport
  • price 1 of 4

Photograph: Mark Wright

Every Chicago neighborhood has its favored thin-crust pie, and for decades, Bridgeport’s preference has been Phil’s. Regulars will tell you all about the former dining room, which was located on Halsted and exuded a bit more charm (and plenty of wood paneling), but the recipe hasn't changed. The owners took their old-school Blodgett ovens with them, and the crispy exterior crust, chewy interior crust and hunks of fennel-flecked sausage honor the tasty tradition of the original.

Morgan Olsen
Global Food & Drink Editor

22.Forno Rosso
  • Pizza
  • West Loop

Forno Rosso owner Nick Nitti studied in Naples to learn to make traditional Neapolitan pizza before opening restaurants in Dunning and the West Loop. Pies bake for about a minute in a wood-burning oven and are typically eaten with a fork and knife, with red and white options including the Carbonara with pancetta, egg and cracked black pepper, and the Barese with rapini, locally sourced sausage and imported burrata. Save room for dessert and order a pizza topped with nutella, bananas, strawberries and powdered sugar.

Samantha Nelson

Advertising

23.Piece Brewery and Pizzeria
  • Pizza
  • Wicker Park
  • price 2 of 4

Photograph: Bradley Danner

Two things keep this place from going the route of sports-bar-beer-bong culture: excellent house brews and expertly executed pizzas. The crispy pies hold a lot of weight, so after you choose your pizza style—red, white, BBQ or New Haven–style “plain” (red sauce, no mozzarella)—start piling on the toppings. (If you’re really going New Haven–style, try one with clams and bacon.) Wash it down with a pint of the crisp Golden Arm, and you’ll never disparagingly say “pizza and beer joint” again.

Morgan Olsen
Global Food & Drink Editor

24.Naudi Signature Pizza
  • Pizza
  • Lake View
Photograph: Zach Long

Naudi Signature Pizza offers pasta, salads and wraps, but you’re here for the namesake. Keep it simple with a square pan or thin-crust white or red pizza topped with fresh basil and a blend of four cheeses, or get more out there with french fries and chicken pizza. You can also try pide, a Turkish flatbread pizza. While you can get the pies delivered or for pickup, it’s best to dine in at the BYOB spot and enjoy a wood-fired pie that’s just been pulled out of the oven.

Samantha Nelson

Advertising

25.Side Street Saloon
  • Sports Bars
  • Lake View
  • price 1 of 4

Regularly packed with locals watching sports or playing pool, Side Street Saloon offers the full neighborhood dive bar experience complete with some excellent tavern-style pizza. It’s cash only, so come prepared and you’ll be rewarded with cracker-thin crust loaded with pepperoni, sausage and giardiniera. It’s cut into tiny pieces, which are perfect for sharing alongside fried pickle chips, cheese curds and a pitcher of beer from a local brewery like Begyle or Half Acre.

Samantha Nelson

26.Pizza Friendly Pizza
  • American
  • Ukrainian Village
  • price 2 of 4

Photograph: Clayton Hauck

In a flip that epitomized 2020, Bite Cafe transformedinto Pizza Friendly Pizza, a scrappy but hopeful collaboration between friends Noah Sandoval (Oriole, Kumiko) and Bruce Finkelman, the managing partner of 16" on Center (Empty Bottle, Bite Cafe). Like its name suggests, the star of the menu is pizza—more specifically, thick Sicilian-style 'za that sports a bubbly crust that's anchored by crispy, caramelized edges. During patio season, head to the alley behind the building, where you'll find a small window plus several tables with plants hanging overhead.

Morgan Olsen
Global Food & Drink Editor

Advertising

27.Burt’s Place
  • Suburbs
  • price 2 of 4

Photograph: Jaclyn Rivas for Time Out

Beloved Morton Grove pizzeria Burt’s Place specializes in deep dish pies that boast a signature caramelized crust developed by late founder Burt Katz, who also previously launched both Gulliver’s and Pequod’s. Stuff yours with whatever you want (we're fans of sausage, onions and mixed bell peppers) and toss in some jalapeño poppers and cannoli for good measure.

Morgan Olsen
Global Food & Drink Editor

28.Coda Di Volpe
  • Lake View
Photograph: Courtesy of Coda di Volpe

Billy Lawless of Gage Hospitality Group and Ryan O’Donnell of Ballyhoo Hospitality teamed up to bring a taste of Southern Italy to the Southport Corridor with Coda di Volpe. Order a Neapolitan pizza topped with squash blossoms, garlic and mint, or opt for a square cut Sicilian-style pie which can also be made gluten-free. Watch the action from the chef’s counter or imagine you’re vacationing in Italy by having a glass of rosé or a spritz at one of the sidewalk tables.

Samantha Nelson

Advertising

29.Dante’s Pizzeria
  • Pizza
  • Logan Square
  • price 1 of 4

Photograph: Martha Williams

Welcome to the “Nine Levels of Hell”: poblano peppers, pepperoni, giardiniera, bacon, fresh garlic, jalapeño, sausage, red onion and banana peppers, together forming the “Inferno.” This pizza sounds terrifying, but trust us, it won’t hurt. The heat’s present but mild-mannered, the thin crust is pleasantly chewy, and the thing is huge. There’s also a vegan version made with sausage and pepperoni from Palermo’s Unreal Foods. If that’s too intense, just stop in for a jumbo slice of pepperoni.

Morgan Olsen
Global Food & Drink Editor

30.Nella Pizza e Pasta
  • Pizza
  • Hyde Park
Marcin Cymer

Owner Nella Grassano is a professionally trained pizzaiola, which essentially means that she's a bonafide pizza expert (talk about a dream job). Grassano and her husband, Francesco, use this training to crank out pristine Neapolitan pies at their Hyde Park restaurant. Go classic with the stripped-down Nella D.O.P., with mozzarella, tomatoes and basil—or turn things up a notch with the Pescatore, a pie loaded with calamari, shrimp, mussels and clams.

Morgan Olsen
Global Food & Drink Editor

Advertising

31.Reno
  • Italian
  • Logan Square
  • price 1 of 4

Photograph: Morgan Olsen

We can't think of a more dynamic duo than pizza and bagels, and lucky for us, Logan Square's Reno specializes in both carbolicious delicacies. Swing by during weekend brunch service for breakfast sandwiches or come in the evening to grab a pie for the road. The menu is rife with far-out flavor combinations that totally work, like the Spanish Monster, with mushrooms, chorizo, cream sauce, scallions and mozzarella. You can certainly share the 14-inch pizzas, but we recommend one per person if you're hoping to have leftovers.

Morgan Olsen
Global Food & Drink Editor

32.Bartoli's Pizzeria
  • Pizza
  • North Center
Photograph: Miles Boone Photography

Brian Tondryk followed in the footsteps of his grandfather, Gino’s East co-founder Fred Bartoli, by opening Bartoli’s Pizzeria in Roscoe Village in 2013 and adding a West Town location in 2020. The restaurants serve both deep dish and tavern-style pizza, with signature pies including the Union Stockyard made with Italian sausage, bacon, pepperoni, prosciutto and Italian beef, and The Diavolo, a spicy blend of soppressata, capocollo, ricotta, Calabrian chili peppers and Mike’s Hot Honey.

Samantha Nelson

Advertising

33.Pizza Lobo
  • Pizza
  • Logan Square
Photograph: Courtesy of Kristen Mendiola

Featured on Season 2 of The Bear, Pizza Lobo features a slice window serving grab-and-go 'za, but you can also share a 16-inch pie along with some frozen cocktails by grabbing a stool at the bar or a spot on the 4,000-square-foot patio. The top seller is the Borgata, topped with pepperoni, ricotta, Calabrian chile honey and basil, though they also have several vegetarian options. For a real deal, order a Miami Vice (a swirl of pina colada and frozen strawberry margarita) and get a slice of cheese pizza for 99 cents.

Samantha Nelson

34.Roots Handmade Pizza
  • Pizza
  • East Village
  • price 1 of 4

Photograph: Neil Burger

Chicagoans have become accustomed to a variety of different styles of pizza: Neapolitan, New York, Detroit and Sicilian. But what the heck is a Quad Cities-style pie? The crust is crafted with dark-roasted malt, which gives it a subtle sweetness and great chew. From there, a slightly spicy sauce is layered with toppings and blanketed in cheese. After baking in the oven, each pie is cut into long strips with a pair of scissors. No matter where you're from, it's a style worth trying—if only for that satisfyingly sweet crust.

Morgan Olsen
Global Food & Drink Editor

Advertising

35.Crushed Pizzeria
  • Pizza
  • Lake View
  • price 2 of 4

Photograph: Courtesy Crushed Pizzeria

A haven for East Coast transplants, Crushed serves 12- and 16-inch pies, with favorites including the Louie made with sausage, spicy capicola, pepperoni, roasted red peppers, cremini mushrooms and the signature crushed tomato sauce, and the Venus, which features sausage, shaved parmesan and caramelized onions. Customize your pie with add-ons including garlic butter sauce, sriracha ranch and pickled jalapeños.Crushed also offer a rotating selection of craft sodas.

Samantha Nelson

Been there, done that? Think again, my friend.

By entering your email address you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and consent to receive emails from Time Out about news, events, offers and partner promotions.

🙌
Awesome, you're subscribed!

Thanks for subscribing! Look out for your first newsletter in your inbox soon!

Been there, done that? Think again, my friend.

By entering your email address you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and consent to receive emails from Time Out about news, events, offers and partner promotions.

🙌
Awesome, you're subscribed!

Thanks for subscribing! Look out for your first newsletter in your inbox soon!

Recommended

    You may also like

    You may also like

    Advertising

    The best pizzas in Chicago right now (2024)

    References

    Top Articles
    Latest Posts
    Recommended Articles
    Article information

    Author: Arielle Torp

    Last Updated:

    Views: 5547

    Rating: 4 / 5 (41 voted)

    Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

    Author information

    Name: Arielle Torp

    Birthday: 1997-09-20

    Address: 87313 Erdman Vista, North Dustinborough, WA 37563

    Phone: +97216742823598

    Job: Central Technology Officer

    Hobby: Taekwondo, Macrame, Foreign language learning, Kite flying, Cooking, Skiing, Computer programming

    Introduction: My name is Arielle Torp, I am a comfortable, kind, zealous, lovely, jolly, colorful, adventurous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.